Updated daily39,201 products compared67 categories145 buying guides How we test Affiliate disclosure
0SavedWishlist0Side by sideCompare
How we test Affiliate disclosure
HP 58A (CF258A) Black Original Toner Cartridge9.4Our score 4 photos
HBrandHPHHP310 products in our catalogSee all 310 HP products →ID DBD-25565

HP 58A (CF258A) Black Original Toner Cartridge

9.4/10 our score 4.7 (3,163 ratings on Amazon)

HP Ink Cartridges are engineered to work with HP printers to provide consistent quality, reliability and value

About this item

  • HP Ink Cartridges are engineered to work with HP printers to provide consistent quality, reliability and value
  • Works with these HP Printers: LaserJet Enterprise M430f,M406dn; LaserJet Pro M404dn,M404n,M428fdw,M428fdn,M404dw,M428dw
  • Cartridge yield (approx.): 3,000 pages
  • Use HP Toner Cartridges to eliminate toner leaks and premature failures
Category: Printers › Toner CartridgesRanked #99 of 211 in Printers
9.4Our score
Our verdict

HP Ink Cartridges are engineered to work with HP printers to provide consistent quality, reliability and value

Ranked #99 in Printers · 4 things we like

Quick answer The HP 58A scores 9.4/10 with us. Amazon owners rate it 4.7 out of 5 across 3,163 reviews, above the 4.1 average of the 6 toner cartridges we track. It was listed at $146.89 on Amazon when we last checked in September 2026.

Expect professional-quality documents when you use Original HP printer cartridges. Dependable performance, consistent page yields, and standout results. With Original HP Toner cartridges, you can also avoid reprints and help ensure the amazing performance you expect from your HP printer.

These toner cartridges for HP printers are used for office, business, and professional printing. It is capable of high capacity, secure chip technology, as well as anti-malware performance. These office supplies are used to reduce downtime, keep printer secure, and ensure consistent outputs.

Be confident that Original HP Toner Cartridges provide the printing experiences crucial for productivity in your office. Count on high-quality, reliable printing and save time by avoiding common printing problems.

Do Best Deal is a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program. As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases. If you buy through links on this site we may earn a commission, at no extra cost to you. Learn more.

Product information

24 specifications
BrandHP
Built-In MediaToner Cartridge
Cartridge TypeGenuine
Number of Packs1
Number of Items1
Unit Count1 Count
Global Trade Identification Number00192018046757
Item Type NameImaging Unit
Model NameCF258A
Model Number58A
Model SeriesHP LaserJet Pro
Mfr Part NumberCF258A
Specific Uses For ProductOffice Printing
Warranty DescriptionHP's Premium Protection Warranty. This HP product is warranted to be free from defects in materials and workmanship. Thi
ColorBlack
Compatible DevicesWorks with these HP Printers: LaserJet Enterprise M430f,M406dn; LaserJet Pro M404dn,M404n,M428fdw,M428fdn,M404dw,M428dw
Compatibility OptionsWorks with these HP Printers: LaserJet Enterprise M430f,M406dn; LaserJet Pro M404dn,M404n,M428fdw,M428fdn,M404dw,M428dw
Other Special Features of the ProductHigh yield (3,000 pages) and recycled content
Page Yield3000
Printer Model CompatibilityHP LaserJet Enterprise M406dn, HP LaserJet Enterprise MFP M430F, HP LaserJet Pro M404DW, HP LaserJet Pro M404N, HP Laser
DuplexSimplex
Item Weight16 ounces
Additional Printer FunctionsPrint Only
Ink ColourBlack

Pros & cons

What we like
  • HP Ink Cartridges are engineered to work with HP printers to provide consistent quality, reliability and value
  • Works with these HP Printers: LaserJet Enterprise M430f,M406dn; LaserJet Pro M404dn,M404n,M428fdw,M428fdn,M404dw,M428dw
  • Cartridge yield (approx.): 3,000 pages
  • Use HP Toner Cartridges to eliminate toner leaks and premature failures
What could be better

    HP 58A: questions & answers

    Is the HP 58A worth buying?

    Yes, it is one of the stronger picks in its group. We score the HP 58A 9.4 out of 10. Amazon owners rate it 4.7 out of 5 across 3,163 reviews, above the 4.1 average of the 6 toner cartridges we track.

    How much does the HP 58A cost?

    It was listed at $146.89 on Amazon when we last checked in September 2026. That is more than the $109.84 median for toner cartridges in our catalog. Amazon prices change daily, so use the price button on this page to see the current figure.

    What options does the HP 58A come in?

    Amazon lists 3 options. Size: 2 Pack, 1 Pack. Style: Toner (Pack of 2), Toner, 2 Pack. Pick an option on this page and the button opens exactly that model.

    What are good alternatives to the HP 58A?

    Similar, well-rated toner cartridges in our catalog: Brother Genuine Standard Yield Toner Cartridge (9.4/10, 4.7 stars from 33,570 owners); Brother Genuine TN229XLBK Black High Yield (9.2/10, 4.6 stars from 524 owners); InkNI Compatible TN850 TN820 Toner Cartridge (8.4/10, 4.2 stars from 54 owners).

    Brother Genuine Standard Yield Toner CartridgeBrother Genuine TN229XLBK Black High YieldInkNI Compatible TN850 TN820 Toner Cartridge

    Customer reviews

    All reviews on Amazon
    4.73,163 global ratings
    5 star90%
    4 star10%
    3 star0%
    2 star0%
    1 star0%

    Breakdown from the 10 most helpful reviews we imported.

    D
    Dali Lolly
    Verified purchaseJune 28, 2026
    Easy

    Works great. Pop it in, ready to print. Even has a return label for the previous spent cartridge.

    N
    Nikhil Gohad
    Verified purchaseSeptember 3, 2026
    Cartridge Replacement

    Flawless delivery. I was able to replace cartridge without any challenges. Printer acknowledged authentic HP cartridge.

    D
    Diane Tucker
    Verified purchaseSeptember 17, 2026
    Toner cartridge

    I've been using this toner cartridge for a long time. I would recommend this product to anyone.

    A
    Amazon Customer
    Verified purchaseAugust 26, 2026
    Great refill

    Wirks well. Go to refill

    J
    Jennie
    Verified purchaseJuly 20, 2026
    excellent product

    Order this item a lot with great service and great product

    M
    Marisa Forzano
    Verified purchaseMarch 25, 2026
    Printer cartridge

    Expensive but it’s what you need for the particular printer

    H
    HV buyer
    Verified purchaseNovember 27, 2024
    Reliable and High-Quality Toner Cartridge

    I recently purchased the HP 58A Black Toner Cartridge for my HP LaserJet printer, and I'm extremely satisfied with its performance. The cartridge was easy to install, and the print quality is exceptional - crisp, clear, and vibrant.I've been using this cartridge for a few weeks now, and I've noticed that it yields a high page count, making it a great value for the price. I've also experienced no issues with compatibility or reliability.Overall, I highly recommend the HP 58A Black Toner Cartridge to anyone looking for a high-quality, reliable toner cartridge for their HP LaserJet printer.Pros:-

    D
    Dohnahue
    Verified purchaseMay 14, 2026
    Trustworthy

    Love the ink and lasts a long time

    Customer reviews are shown as published on Amazon and are not written by Do Best Deal.