Charcoal asks more of the cook than gas does, and gives more back. There is a fire to light and manage, ash to empty, and no knob to turn the heat down, but the reward is the high, dry heat and smoke that make a burger or a rack of ribs taste like a cookout. Everything in a charcoal grill’s design is about controlling that fire. Vents meter the air that feeds it. A charcoal pan that moves up and down changes the distance between coals and food, which is the nearest thing to a heat dial. A lid with a thermometer turns the grill into an oven for slow cooking, and an offset firebox adds real smoking. We went through the charcoal grills in our garden and outdoor catalog and ranked them on cooking area, heat control, convenience and what owners report.
We have not cooked on these grills ourselves; the verdicts rest on the spec sheets and the owner review history. Prices are not printed because they change daily; every button opens the live Amazon page. Cooking areas are quoted from each listing. If you would rather turn a knob, see our portable propane grills guide, and for apartments where open flame is not allowed, our indoor electric grills guide.
How we picked
- Charcoal only. Barrel grills, offset smoker combos and portable charcoal grills; no gas, pellet or electric models.
- Stated cooking area. Main grate, warming rack and smoker chamber as the listing breaks them down.
- Heat control. Adjustable charcoal pans, vents, smoke stacks and lid thermometers.
- Convenience. Side tables, wheels, ash handling and storage shelves.
- Owner feedback. Best-reviewed first; one portable has a small number of owner reviews and is labelled.
The picks
Royal Gourmet CC1830 28 Inch Barrel Charcoal Grill, Side Table

The CC1830 is the grill we would put in most backyards. It is a 28 inch barrel with 626 square inches of cooking space, split between 475 square inches of porcelain-enameled steel wire grate and a 151 square inch chrome-plated warming rack, enough for a family cookout with room to move food off the heat. Control comes from three places: a charcoal pan that lifts to two heights to change the distance between coals and food, a side air vent, and an adjustable smoke stack. Close the vent fully when you finish and the fire is starved of oxygen, which saves the unburned charcoal for next time. A lid-mounted thermometer shows the temperature inside, a side shelf with hooks holds tools and seasonings, and two wheels make it easy to roll across a patio. More than a thousand owners give it a very strong owner rating, the best of the full-size grills here.
- More than a thousand owner reviews with a very strong owner rating
- Charcoal pan raises and lowers to change the heat
- Closing the vent snuffs the coals when you finish
- Side shelf, tool hooks and wheels
- No offset firebox for true smoking
- Thin steel wire grates, not cast iron
- Two pan heights, where the DNKMOR offers four
Royal Gourmet CC1830S BBQ Charcoal Grill and Offset Smoker, Outdoor Camping

The CC1830S is the same barrel with a firebox bolted to the side, and that changes what it can do. Build a small fire in the 197 square inch offset chamber and heat and smoke are drawn across the main grate for ribs, brisket and pulled pork, or grill directly over coals in the main chamber as on any barrel. Total cooking area is 823 square inches. A side door on the firebox lets you add charcoal and rake out ash without lifting the lid, an air vent stokes the fire, the charcoal pan adjusts to two heights, and a lid thermometer tracks the temperature. Front and side tables give working space, and the bottom shelf holds up to 20 pounds. It is the most reviewed grill here, with thousands of owner reviews and a strong owner rating. Budget offset smokers need attention to hold temperature.
- Thousands of owner reviews, by far the most in this guide
- Offset firebox for low and slow smoking
- Largest total cooking area here
- Front and side tables plus a storage shelf
- Owner rating is strong, a step below the CC1830
- Offset smokers take practice to hold a steady temperature
- Bottom shelf carries only 20 lb, evenly spread
Royal Gourmet CC1830V 30 Barrel Charcoal Grill with Side Front Table

The CC1830V is the third Royal Gourmet barrel and the one to pick if cleanup is what puts you off charcoal. Its adjustable fire grate lifts to two heights with handles, like the others, but the maker also describes it as an easy-to-dump ash pan, so the spent coals come out in one go instead of being scooped. The layout differs slightly from the top pick: a 443 square inch porcelain-enameled main grate with a larger 184 square inch chrome-plated warming rack, and both a side and a front table, which gives you somewhere to put a tray directly in front of the lid. Heat control is by the side air vent and smoke stack, with a lid-mounted gauge for the temperature. More than a thousand owners give it a strong owner rating. It and the CC1830 are close relatives; check both live pages and buy whichever layout you prefer.
- Charcoal pan doubles as an easy-dump ash pan
- Both a side and a front table
- Larger warming rack than the CC1830
- More than a thousand owner reviews with a strong owner rating
- Slightly smaller main grate than the CC1830
- Very similar to the top pick, so compare both on the day
- No offset firebox
Charcoal Grill with Side Table,Barrel BBQ Grill 500 Sq In Cooking Area

This barrel grill, sold under the DNKMOR name in its bullets, costs noticeably less than the Royal Gourmet models and has one feature they lack: a charcoal pan with four height levels instead of two. That gives you finer steps between searing close to the coals and gentle cooking further away, and the pan holds up to 4.5 pounds of charcoal. The cooking area is given as about 500 square inches across the porcelain-enameled grates and a chrome-plated warming rack, smaller than the grills above but enough for a family. A lid-mounted thermometer, a large side table, two wheels and a side handle for moving it are all included. The bullets we have do not describe the vents or a smoke stack, so look at the photos on the live page. Hundreds of owners give it a strong owner rating, level with the CC1830V.
- Four charcoal pan heights give finer heat control
- Lowest-cost full-size grill in this guide
- Lid thermometer and side table included
- Hundreds of owner reviews with a strong owner rating
- Smaller cooking area than the Royal Gourmet grills
- Brand appears only in the bullets, not the title
- Vents and smoke stack are not described in the bullets we have
BRANDMAN GRILLS SINCE 1987 2 in 1 Portable Charcoal BBQ Rotisserie Grill

The BRANDMAN is an unusual thing: a foldable charcoal grill that weighs under 25 pounds and still turns a chicken on a spit. The motor-driven rotisserie rotates a full 360 degrees, the spit sits at any of three heights to bring the meat closer to or further from the coals, and lockable tines on the forks hold it steady. Meanwhile the 21 inch, almost 260 square inch porcelain-enameled grate works as a conventional grill, and the maker says both can be used at once. Eight adjustable air vents on the two sides manage the burn. Folded, it fits in a car trunk, and the maker sizes it for three to five people at a lake, a campsite or a tailgate. The bullets do not say how the motor is powered, so check whether you need batteries or a socket. Dozens of owners give it a strong owner rating.
- Motorized rotisserie on a grill you can carry
- Folds flat for a car trunk
- Eight vents for airflow control
- Dozens of owner reviews with a strong owner rating
- No lid thermometer mentioned
- Feeds three to five people, per the maker
- How the rotisserie motor is powered is not stated in the bullets we have
Charcoal Grill Offset Smoker: Charcoal Barbecue Grills

If the CC1830S is more grill than your patio can take, this compact combo gives you the same two-chamber idea in less space. The total cooking surface is 512 square inches across the main grill and the offset smoker, with a warming rack, and the maker pitches it at smaller family cookouts. A thermometer in the main lid lets you watch the temperature without opening it, and adjustable air vents on both the grill and the smoker regulate airflow and smoke. Cart-style wheels and stainless steel handles make it easy to move, and there are two storage areas. It ranks sixth on feedback: it has hundreds of owner reviews, but its owner rating is solid, the lowest in this guide, and the title carries no brand name. The bullets do not mention an adjustable charcoal pan either.
- Offset smoking in a smaller footprint
- Vents on both chambers
- Hundreds of owner reviews
- Wheels, handles and storage included
- Owner rating is solid, the lowest in this guide
- No brand name in the title
- No adjustable charcoal pan is mentioned
GasOne 14-inch Portable Charcoal Barbecue Grill with Thermometer Lux Brown

The GasOne is the smallest grill here, a 14 inch portable with 150 square inches of cooking surface, which is enough for a couple of steaks or a few burgers. Its best feature is the lid: a three-point locking system clamps it down, which the maker says helps trap heat for more even cooking, and which also keeps the grate and ash inside when you carry it to the car. A dual ventilation system keeps air moving through the coals, an ash catcher underneath stops residue falling onto the ground, and the title lists a thermometer. It is the sort of grill that lives in a trunk for parks, beaches and campsites. Our reservation is the evidence: it has a small number of owner reviews so far, and although the rating from that limited owner feedback is excellent, it is too early to call it proven. That is why it is seventh.
- Locking lid keeps everything together in transit
- Ash catcher limits mess on a patio or picnic table
- Light and compact for camping and balconies where allowed
- Excellent owner rating so far
- Only a small number of owner reviews so far
- 150 sq in suits two people, not a crowd
- No height adjustment for the charcoal
Compare the picks
| Product | Type | Cooking area | Heat control | Standout feature | Our score | Our score | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Royal Gourmet CC1830Royal Gourmet | Barrel | 626 sq in | 2-level pan, vent, stack | Side shelf with hooks | 9/10 | 9.0 | See price |
Royal Gourmet CC1830SRoyal Gourmet | Barrel with offset smoker | 823 sq in | 2-level pan, firebox vent | Offset firebox with side door | 8.6/10 | 8.6 | See price |
Royal Gourmet CC1830VRoyal Gourmet | Barrel | 443 plus 184 sq in | 2-height pan, vent, stack | Easy-dump ash pan, two tables | 8.8/10 | 8.8 | See price |
DNKMOR barrel grillDNKMOR | Barrel | About 500 sq in | 4-level pan | Lowest-cost full-size grill | 8.8/10 | 8.8 | See price |
BRANDMAN rotisserie portableBRANDMAN GRILLS SINCE 1987 | Foldable portable | Almost 260 sq in | 8 air vents, 3 spit heights | Motorized rotisserie | 8.7/10 | 8.7 | See price |
Compact offset smoker comboSUNLIFER | Grill with offset smoker | 512 sq in | Vents on both chambers | Smaller two-chamber design | 8/10 | 8.0 | See price |
GasOne 14 inch portableGas One | Portable kettle style | 150 sq in | Dual vents | 3-point locking lid | 8.7/10 | 8.7 | See price |
Barrel, offset or portable?
A barrel grill is the all-rounder: a long grate for cooking in zones, a lid for roasting, and enough room for a party. Add an offset firebox and you can smoke properly, with the fire in one chamber and the food in the other, at the cost of a bigger footprint and a steeper learning curve, because thin-walled budget smokers lose heat quickly in wind and cold. Portables trade capacity for the ability to go where the food is eaten. As a guide to size, 150 square inches feeds two, 260 feeds three to five, and 450 or more on the main grate handles a family gathering.
Controlling heat on a charcoal grill
There are three levers. The amount of charcoal sets the upper limit. Air sets the burn rate: open vents mean a hotter fire, and closing them cools it and eventually puts it out. Distance does the fine tuning, which is why an adjustable charcoal pan is worth having; raise it to sear, lower it to cook through. On any barrel, bank the coals to one side to create a hot zone and a cooler zone, sear over the first and finish over the second with the lid down. Trust the lid thermometer as a rough guide only, since it reads the air near the lid, not the grate.
Safety and care
Charcoal produces carbon monoxide, so use these grills outdoors only, never in a garage, tent or enclosed porch, and keep them on a level, non-combustible surface well away from walls, railings and overhanging branches. Use only lighter products intended for charcoal, never gasoline, and do not add lighter fluid to coals that are already lit. Keep children and pets clear, and remember the lid and body stay hot long after cooking. When you finish, close the vents and let the coals burn out; empty ash only when it is completely cold, into a metal container. Brush the grates while warm, empty ash after every cook because damp ash corrodes steel, and keep the grill covered or under shelter.
What size charcoal grill do I need?
About 150 square inches feeds two people, around 260 feeds three to five, and 450 square inches or more on the main grate suits family gatherings. The Royal Gourmet barrels in this guide offer 443 to 475 square inches on the main grate plus a warming rack.
Is an offset smoker worth it on a charcoal grill?
If you want to cook ribs, brisket or pulled pork low and slow, yes. The Royal Gourmet CC1830S adds a 197 square inch firebox to a full barrel grill. If you mostly grill burgers and steaks, a plain barrel is simpler and cheaper.
How do you control the temperature on a charcoal grill?
With air and distance. Open vents feed the fire and raise the heat; closing them lowers it. An adjustable charcoal pan changes how close the coals are to the food. The DNKMOR grill has four pan heights and the Royal Gourmet barrels have two.
Can I use a charcoal grill on a balcony or indoors?
Never indoors or in any enclosed space, because burning charcoal gives off carbon monoxide. Balcony use depends on local fire rules and building policy, and many prohibit charcoal. Check before buying, and consider an electric grill if open flame is not allowed.
How do I clean a charcoal grill?
Brush the grates while they are still warm, then let the coals die with the vents closed. Once the ash is completely cold, empty it into a metal container. The Royal Gourmet CC1830V has an easy-dump ash pan that makes this quicker.
Prices and stock change daily. The buttons above open Amazon so you always see the current price. Do Best Deal may earn a commission if you buy through them, at no extra cost to you.
Do Best Deal is a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program. As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases. If you buy through links on this site we may earn a commission, at no extra cost to you. Learn more.
